After a walk in a nearby quaint neighborhood and pouring over the Cottage Living website, I was completly inspired. After trying Cottage Dreams builder, I realized that what I really needed was shutters and window boxes.
I fired up photoshop, dug up a picture of my house and went to work. After adding these elements, I think it really does look better! Check out the before and after! I printed out the sheet and left it on the counter for Aaron. I see a trip to Home Depot in the near future.